THE SHACK: A Spiritual Journey Sparking Controversy

THE SHACK: A Spiritual Journey Sparking Controversy
The Shack (2017) - source: Summit Entertainment

From Stuart Hazeldine, a director with very few credits to his name, The Shack has provided a positive breakthrough in the consortium of films that involve a strong presence of faith. But whilst audiences are able to relish in the spiritual and uplifting undertones of the story, it has somewhat proven to be a bit of a controversial storm amongst its critics.

Based on the New York Times best-selling novel, The Shack takes us on a mourning father’s tragic yet inspirational journey. After suffering a family tragedy, Mackenzie ‘Mack’ Phillips (Sam Worthington) spirals into a deep depression; causing him to question his inner beliefs.

Facing a crisis of faith, he receives a mysterious letter urging him to make his way to an abandoned shack deep in the Oregon wilderness. Despite his doubts, Mack makes the journey, and encounters an enigmatic trio of strangers symbolising the Holy Trinity, led by a woman named Papa (Octavia Spencer). Through this meeting, Mack finds important truths that will transform his understanding of the tragedy he’s experienced and change his way of thinking; ultimately altering his life forever.

Enlightening Or Dispiriting?

On one hand, we can look upon The Shack as a guide to understanding forgiveness and helping to process our grievances in a healthy way. This is undoubtedly the intention William P. Young had when he authored the novel back in 2007. To an extent, this is a believable mantra throughout the narrative of the movie, because of the impeccable acting from Spencer and Worthington. Their talents on-screen are undeniable, and the chemistry between the majority of the characters is very effective.

On the other hand, it’s been suggested that the film comes across as rather offensive and due to this, has sparked up a lot of debate with its audiences.

There appears to be a crossover between what is acceptable and what isn’t when it comes to the symbolisation of faith on the big screen. When Mack meets the three individuals, he immediately assumes that they represent the Trinity, but is surprised when he asks for God and all three of the gracious figures answer him. This reignited the controversy behind the theology of modalism, which says that God is one individual, presenting itself in three different ways – but is ultimately still one person.

Another argument that has circled around since before the film was even planned to be released, is the question of whether or not God really should be addressed as female. Although Papa is different from the way God is biblically characterised in gender, she still holds all the other necessary ideologies required to represent and embody this character. Papa is still compassionate, loving, peaceful and fully invested in Mack’s wellbeing. Which – for many – is where the frustration lies, but for others, is a delightful quality to the overall perception of the movie.

THE SHACK: A Spiritual Journey Sparking Controversy
Octavia Spencer As ‘Papa’ – source: Summit Entertainment

The book’s original publisher, Wayne Jacobsen, has recently explained that the decision to see God as a woman – and perhaps more importantly, as non-white – was to show that God can reveal himself and work through anyone.

However, the plot thickens further when we look at it from a heavily religious perspective. It could be argued that the film is too much of an emotional anchor, and that the use of a black woman as God is primarily designed to shut down any predicted opposition. Given that Papa is represented as a minority and as a woman, it could allow for claims of racism and sexism to anyone who objects or opposes to the unique theology.

But then why should God be so one-dimensional? The Shack paves the way for anyone of any faith and of their own beliefs to evaluate their own individual outlook, which provides leverage for all audiences to make a distinctive connection to the story and its characters.

A Raw Sentiment

Hazeldine, whose only previous feature is the 2009 psychological thriller Exam, chooses to take the route of stripped-back cinematography and eased paces from beginning to end. Visually, Mack’s sacred encounters in the deserted setting are pretty, especially the colourful diagrammatic of the surrounding gardens which are key to epitomise the tranquility of the setting. However, the visuals are still never particularly soul-stirring or enthralling. Even with esteemed cinematographer Declan Quinn on hand, crucial transitions seem to be rather lost, and the understated dramatic power of the real, natural setting seems wasted.

THE SHACK: A Spiritual Journey Sparking Controversy
source: Summit Entertainment

The benefit of this, however, is being able to focus more on the raw emotion and sentiment of the underlined story beyond special effects and clichéd gimmicks. This is essentially a journey of a character who has experienced a most tragic experience and needs healing in more ways than one. So whilst this makes for quite a distressing viewing, it is needed to create an authentic and convincing impact.

It’s clear that Hazeldine and his design crew wanted to shoot these supernatural encounters in a relatable light, which is an approach that’s echoed even in the screenplay and the dialogue.

Final Thoughts

The Shack successfully manages to challenge the narrow conceptions of what a Christian looks or sounds like – hence all of the debate and controversy. But it’s not necessarily the film’s ideas that are its problem, but the realness with which they’re explored.

It’s understandable to see why Christians may be up in arms at this portrayal of faith, because it’s one of the only instances where religious figures have been presented as physical beings and in this case, are depicted a bit like the featured celebrity guests of a talk show.

But The Shack also has a good chance of connecting commercially, because even though its drama is rather mushy, it’s a bit like a dream, whereas in real life, religion isn’t nearly as reassuring. Our current culture is starved for films that portray religious feelings in a way that’s relatable, and The Shack certainly does this. In some ways, it reduces faith to a kind of spiritual comfort food.

But maybe that’s what faith is on its way to becoming – and is that such a bad thing? How can we compare our own view of faith to someone else’s? In this instance it’s solely Mack’s experience – so who are we to judge?

Do you think The Shack succeeds at providing us with a religiously healing escape, or do you agree with the critics?

The Shack opened in the U.S. on March 3. The film will see release in the U.K. on June 9.

https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=CL0yUbSS5Eg

I’m Alice. I’m a writer, blogger, film nerd, determined dreamer, foodie, vino inhaler and reality TV nut. I have ambitions to become a crazy dog lady in the very near future – www.welcometothelabyrinth.wordpress.com
Opinions expressed in our articles are those of the authors and not of the Film Inquiry magazine.
  • Astromoney

    It is deeply Spiritual.
    It is deeply Philosophical.
    It is deeply human.
    It is deeply emotionally, intellectually and spiritually expansive.
    What is sad is the depth to which our great masses have fallen in that the majority reporting here have been coarsened to a degree where they no longer recognize beauty, sensitivity, creativity and the power of human love and forgiveness.

  • Ross H

    The author Paul Young does not suggest “modalism” in his beliefs or in his book “The Shack”. In fact, Young suggests a traditional understanding of the Trinity where one God in three persons live in a fellowship with each other. The love and relationship between the three persons of the Trinity is important because it informs the concept that the very nature of God is to love. “GOD IS LOVE” makes no sense if God has existed at one time as a singular being that needs and loves nothing. God has always existed within a relationship of love… within the Trinity.

    Otherwise, it appears that there is some lack in God that is fulfilled by creating something to love and to love Him… (mankind). As if God was lonely and needed to buy a puppy for himself….. But before the creation of man there was nothing missing so to speak for God, because he existed within the perfect loving relationship of the Trinity.